We’ve had our first visit by a perspective buyer this
week, which makes me realize that it’s time to start thinking seriously about
our next boat. Having been through this
before not so long ago, I know that this task is a labyrinth riddled with false
starts and wrong turns. It reminds me of
Somerset Maugham’s famous quip about writing:
“There are three rules to good writing.
Unfortunately, no one knows what they are.”
But one must be brave and start somewhere and the
conventional wisdom says one must start by defining the navigational program,
which should help narrow down the boat choices.
Or not.
The first problem is that our sailing dreams are of
the “leasing with an option to buy” sort.
We’d like to sail around the world (trade winds route is good enough for
me) but we’re just not courageous enough for that yet. So the idea is to head down into the Med, gain
some experience and confidence with multi-day passages and foreign waters, and
if all goes well, buy the dream and head off over the horizon.
This complicates boat choices, though. A full-time live-aboard world cruiser is not
the same as a fair-weather Mediterranean cruiser. Should we aim for the low end of the spectrum
and work our way up, or go straight for a world cruiser as the better
long-term investment? There are knowledgeable
people out there who say that almost any boat rated for offshore cruising is
capable of crossing oceans these days, and it is often said (because it’s true)
that navigational programs are more limited by the crew than by the boat.
I’m a firm believer that one shouldn’t make
things harder than they have to be, no matter how fun it is, so let me be
honest about my dilemma. I WANT a new 40-foot
Hallberg-Rassy or Najad but can’t afford them without selling the house (which
I haven’t entirely ruled out.)
![]() |
| Hallberg Rassy 40 |
See how clear
things can be when you address the root cause?
Now the problem has been reduced to figuring out how to fall in love
with a lesser boat.
If you read our post about boat shopping the first time around, you will no doubt appreciate the maturing process that has taken
place since that time. Earlier, we
decided that boat choices should be driven primarily by lust. Now we know better. Sort of.
Because safety is a major concern of ours, I’ve spent
the last week calculating capsize ratios for a handful of different boats and
reading the available naval architecture blogs, which have now convinced me
that the capsize ratios thus calculated are a lot of bunk. Next, I started going blind staring at the
stability index numbers (STIX, SSSN, and AVS) produced by the British Royal Yachting
Association for hundreds of boats, and in the end, realized that any boat that
meets the Category A criteria is, by definition, safe for offshore
sailing. In saying this, it’s important
to know what Category A means: Unlimited
Ocean Cruising, adequate to withstand up to force 10 gale (55 knots, 102 km/hr,
63 MPH) with average waves of 7 meters height and eventual wave heights up to
14 meters. After having pounded through a
long afternoon of 4 meter seas with a force 8 gale last summer, I don’t want to
get anywhere close to the maximum for the rating. This is certainly not to say that all
Category A boats are created equal but they all should be safe enough for what
we intend to do.
The exercise has been a useful one, however, since I
have now convinced myself that I am not going to be able to calculate my way
out of a difficult choice. Putting all
our dreams and desires into the magic box and turning the handle has only
produced sausage in my mind, not the miracle solution I was looking for. Compromises must be made. Back to square
one.
What is it about Spray
that makes her inappropriate for our future sailing program? I’ve mentioned these before so I’ll only
highlight: too small to live aboard 6
months of the year comfortably, too physical, too low in the water, too light,
too low on tankage. But after a little
reflection, I realized that it’s equally important to list the things we love
about her to try not to lose those elements in this process.
- Robust construction with quality materials.
- Seaworthiness.
- Lots of stowage space for her size.
- Respectability. Every time we pull into port, people come up to us and tell us what a great boat she is. It’s become like a scene from the movie Groundhog Day. “What kind of boat do you have?” “A Dehler 34.” “Oh, great boat.” Same thing, every time. Nice !
- Small. What the ?! I know, I know - it’s crazy ! We’re selling her because we want to buy a BIGGER boat. But I like the fact that we can pull into ports and not have to worry about finding a place to park her. I like that I can step down gently from her decks onto the dock and physically coax her svelte four tonnes into place without bow thrusters. I like that people don’t see us as a bling-bling couple of retirees in a flashy plastic bimbo palace.
This makes one thing clear. We need a boat that’s small on the outside
and big on the inside.
But wait …seriously
now, maybe it means that we could be happy with a boat well under 40 feet if
the layout is good, in which case, maybe we could afford an older, smaller
version of the HRs or Najads? To be
continued…





.jpg)



































