Monday, 25 June 2012

Wither SSB ?

One of my favourite finds during our recent inventory of Spray was the Sony 7600 single sideband radio receiver.  When I was a kid, my sister and I became amateur “ham” radio operators (Kentucky hams, we used to call ourselves).  We spent many happy evenings eavesdropping on conversations, news and music from around the world, dreaming of the travels and adventures we would have.    

A shiny new Sony 7600 (the one I want...)
Despite the many miraculous technological advances of the past 30 years, shortwave radio is still the best way for global cruisers to have news and information from just about anywhere on the planet.  Some AM/FM radio stations can be picked up along the coast for 50-75 miles.  Beyond that, if you want to stay in touch with what’s going on in the world, you have to rely on signals bounced off the ionosphere, which is shortwave or World Band Radio.  During a brief stroll along the dial (“dial” is what older folks call the seek tuning button) you can stumble onto a mix of traditional music from Southeast Asia, a documentary about maple syrup harvesting from Canada, and dire warnings from doomsday cults broadcasting from….well, they never really say. 

You may be asking yourself how useful (or indeed, desirable) it would be to have the ability to listen to, say, classic Chinese opera while at sea.  But you would be ignoring the fact that a SSB radio not only captures radio broadcasts, it also provides access to all-important weather and navigation information at sea beyond the reach of the marine VHF radio.  Combined with a computer and a good antenna, you can obtain both text and graphic weather data anywhere in the world.  Add a transmitter, and you are wired to participate in the global village. 

There are many radio nets established especially for cruisers by amateur radio operators around the major cruising destinations of the world (or more specifically, major cruising destinations of the world where old hams go to retire, which is to say, predominantly in areas with warm turquoise waters, palm trees, plastic flip-flops, and little fruity drinks with umbrellas … hmmmm, I wonder if I have to be 65 to join them ?).  These nets provide local sailing and port information, reports of piracy, queries from worried families about late arrivals, general gossip, and message relays.  They broadcast at a fixed time every day, providing a great source of entertainment, a bit like Garrison Keillor’s “Lake Woebegone Days” on the high seas.

What breaks my heart is that SSB is now most often labelled as “not dead yet”.  The satellite phone and the ability to connect to the internet from anywhere on the globe is rapidly undermining radio services.  On 31 December 2011, Radio France International announced that it would no longer broadcast offshore weather reports on short wave, depriving French sailors of one of their only sources of offshore weather news from a human voice.  An informal poll on Sail the World suggested, however, that the howl of protest was mostly an elderly one, with younger sailors greeting the news of the terminated broadcast with “so what?” 

While it is tempting at this juncture to dive into the sociological ramifications of this finding, I think I would prefer to avoid the debate altogether and just install both a SSB system and a satellite phone on Spray.  But I sure hope those radio net communities are still around when I’m ready to settle down and plant my toes in the warm sand somewhere.  And a final word to the younger generation of sailors who remain stubbornly insensible to the human connection:  when the robots rise up to enslave and kill us all*, the only place that will be safe is on a boat surrounded by salt water, and you can be sure that all us survivors will be coordinating our efforts via good old shortwave radio. 

Addendum:  After being mercilessly teased by my former colleagues for my naïveté regarding a robot’s ability to operate in salt water, I humbly admit that this was an inexcusable oversight on my part.  After having worked for more than 10 years coordinating bits of the Global Ocean Observing System, I should have immediately thought of the Argo and Glider programmes, which are based on autonomous or remotely-operated floats.  In my own defence, to call them robots at this point is a BIT of an exaggeration.  Nevertheless, I did take this opportunity to remind my friends working on Argo that it is not too early to be thinking about a global “kill switch” for those little buggers.

For a list of maritime radio nets around the world, check out the Noonsite Communications pages.  http://www.noonsite.com/General/Communications

Also on Noonsite, read “The Essential Role of HF/SSB Radio in Ocean Cruising” by Allan Riches.  http://www.noonsite.com/Members/val/R2012-06-02-2

Wednesday, 20 June 2012

The Learning Curve Blues


We knew that reconditioning and outfitting a 20 year old boat, even one in excellent condition, would involve a steep learning curve.  But what we didn’t realize is that the learning curve is, in fact, multiple curves that keep cropping up relentlessly.  It reminds us of running a trail marathon, where you grunt your way up a major hill and experience relief and elation on reaching the top…only to have your gaze settle on the rest of the trail in front of you, which rolls up and over numerous other hills that stretch out as far as the eye can see.   

We were just beginning to get comfortable with all the epoxies, catalysers, and putties one needs to patch up a boat, and gaining confidence in our own abilities to repair things.  After having refurbished an old house together, I learned once again to appreciate Patrick’s DIY skills.  He doesn’t always do things in what I would consider to be the most logical manner, but when he’s finished with something, it’s both solid and aesthetically pleasing.  When we drew up our “To Do” list, we made mental notes about who we would ask for advice or help with each task.  Slowly we’ve begun to realize with a certain timid pride that we can tackle many of them ourselves.

But our relief and elation at our new-found independence was short-lived as new challenges arose this week.  On our Maintenance Log is a seemingly simple task:  have an electric windlass installed.  While this is no simple operation, we would be paying someone else to do it, which I thought meant that this task would require little intervention on our part.  Pay money, cross something off the list, right ? 

The chain locker
So we met with the electrician to discuss the installation of said windlass. First, he terrified us with suggestions of cutting into the forward cabin and shortening it by several feet to improve the slope of the chain locker (“You guys don’t intend for anyone to actually sleep here, right?”).  After he saw our pale faces, he looked around at several other boats in the yard and found a solution that didn’t involve major alterations.  We will have to cut the chain locker hatch in half and stratify the forward part to have a solid base for the windlass, but that should be the only modification needed.

To test the placement of the windlass and the clearance for the anchor and chain, we lowered the anchor over the side and noticed that the anchor arm pitches upwards and hits the genoa furler as it goes over the davit (or comes up).  Two options were presented: either we manually put the anchor into position on the davit to avoid hitting the furler or we extend the davit a bit.   

The next problem was that even once the anchor is beyond the davit, the anchor blade tends to bang into the prow, which argues for extending the davit.  Since the prow also already has some dings that need repair (probably from hauling up the anchor with the chain raking against the prow), it was also suggested that a metal plate protecting the prow would be a good idea.

We next went inside to look at the battery for the motor that will be used to power the windlass.  Long story short: It’s too small. We have to buy a new one.

That simple task “have electric windlass installed” is now:
  • Cut the chain locker hatch in half and stratify the forward section
  • Buy and install an extension for the davit
  • Buy and install a metal plate to protect the prow
  • Buy and install a new battery
  • … and then “have electric windlass installed”. 
We’ve been spending 3-4 hours every day working on the boat and still haven’t managed to cross many items off our “To Do” list.  When we’re home, we’re on the internet researching models and prices of various pieces of equipment, reading forums for advice, or emailing friends for help.  We work from 10 in the morning until 8 at night every day, and we’re starting to get tired and cranky !  Summer sailing Plan A evaporated weeks ago, and now summer sailing Plan B is starting to look overly ambitious as well.  But as with running a tough race, we’re simply going to have to lie convincingly to ourselves that if we can just get up and over that next hill, things will get easier, and then set ourselves the goal of finishing with no injuries and big smiles on our faces.  

Monday, 11 June 2012

Ghost Ship Inventory


In 1872, three crew members of the Canadian freighter Dei Gratia boarded a vessel they encountered drifting 400 miles off the coast of Portugal.  Not a soul was found on board, and yet the ship showed no signs of damage or a hurried departure.  The crew had simply vanished, and the ghost ship Mary Celeste entered into maritime legend.* 
* For fans of maritime history (and chemistry !), I highly recommend the excellent book GhostShip by Brian Hicks … all will be revealed. 

1st layer of stuff in the cockpit locker.
You may think me a drama queen, but I was strangely reminded of this story the first time we boarded Spray as owners and began the inventory of the equipment left behind.  The standard equipment that was listed in the “for sale” announcement was all there.  But there were also sacks of lines, nets, tarps, bungee cords, gas cans, buckets, fishing equipment, hoses, flashlights, cleaning products, paint cans, putty and gelcoat supplies, rolls of wire and spare cables, wheel and motor parts, kitchen utensils, glasses and dishes, coffee, pillows, and three rolls of toilet paper.  Even if the crew had simply vanished, the boat still carried more supplies than many coastal cruisers we know, and we were reminded that the boat had most recently been outfitted for a trans-Atlantic crossing.   

A small sampling of paints and putties.
Since our list of hull repair tasks was growing by the day, I started the inventory with the mysterious crate of cans and tubes found in the cockpit lockers: 7 kinds of grease, numerous bottles of acetone, turpentine, and motor oil, and 18 varieties of putty, hardeners, catalyzers, and gelcoat paint and polish.  I carefully wrote down the name of each product and read the instructions to try to figure out what each was for.  I thought about labelling things, but was stopped by a fit of giggles when I remembered the scene in Gabriel Garcia Marquez’s One Hundred Years of Solitude where the citizens of Macondo lose their memories and start labelling things: “This is a cow.  It gives milk.”  I imagined my first label: “This is polyester for the rudder.  It needs a hardener” but quickly realized that such labels would be more fun than functional. 


After we finished the inventory, we checked with Antoine and Caroline to make sure they had intended to leave all this stuff (in fact, they wanted the kitchen utensils back).  Our next mission is to decide what to remove from the boat.  We are not planning a trans-Atlantic hop anytime soon and don’t need to haul around such a vast supply of emergency repair products.  All those chemicals in the lockers remind me of my first year in college when I decided to double-major in chemistry and marine transportation !

Saturday, 9 June 2012

The Naked Truth, Part II


A friend-of-a-friend dropped by the boatyard today to take a look at our propeller shaft tube problem.  At first, he was convinced that we just needed to patch up the stratification on either end of the shaft, but we decided to go ahead and open up the crack a bit to see what the tube looked like a little further back.  Doing so revealed a pit in the tube about 2cm x 1cm completely eaten away by rust.  When we dug a bit further, the tube pulled away from the stratification with little effort. 

Propellor shaft mysteries resolved.
So the good news is that we no longer have any doubt that the tube must be changed, and personally, we feel a bit vindicated in our insistence that there just might be a problem.  The bad news is that Spray now has a gaping hole where the prop shaft tube used to be and we can’t get this fixed until early July.  And the cherry on the cake is that this is not a cheap operation, even doing the work with friends.

We also just received the estimate from the boatyard for the epoxy work on the keel and hull.  I don’t know if my liver will be able to take another month of such surprises.
Posted on Saturday, June 09, 2012 | Categories:

Thursday, 7 June 2012

Zephyr of Nantes is Spray of Vannes !


It’s official, at least as far as the French administration is concerned.  Zephyr of Nantes has been replaced by Spray of Vannes !

From Er Gwennick to Zephyr to Spray, and the new proud owner.

The process was Kafkaesque as expected, but we managed to get it done in just under 7 hours.  Last night, we went to “The Official Web Site of the French Administration” to learn what steps we had to take to register the boat, to change the home port, and to change the name of the boat.  Let’s just forget the fact that many of the steps outlined by the web site had links to important information on other pages that told you the same stuff that was on the first page, but with the helpful suggestion that if you wanted the really important information, you should go to the following link, which took you right back where you were in the first place.

Here are the official instructions:

The seller must deliver to the Customs Office of the home port of the boat :

·         The sales contract, including all information concerning the boat and its administrative situation.  It must be signed by the Maritime Administration.
·         The acte de francisation (proof of registration and annual duties paid)
·         The “pleasure craft form” filled out in the name of the buyer, in 2 copies
·         2 identity photos of the buyer
·         1 original photo identification of the buyer.

If you want to change the home port,  you must:
·         Fill out the form requesting the change of home port ; present this request to the Customs Offices of  both the current home port and the new home port.

Here, as we discovered, is the reality:

The seller  (the buyer does this now) must deliver to the Customs Office of the home port of the boat :

·         The sales contract, including all information concerning the boat and its administrative situation.  It must be signed by the Maritime Administration.  (They don’t do this anymore, which cuts out one step if you actually know about it, which of course, you can’t know about until you present yourself at the Maritime Administration office.)
·         The acte de francisation (proof of registration and annual duties paid).
·         The “pleasure craft form” filled out in the name of the buyer, in 2 copies.  The Customs Office said that this was for the Maritime Administration. The Maritime Administration officer said she didn’t want it.
·         2 identity photos of the buyer.
·         1 original photo identification of the buyer.

On calling the Customs Office, we are also told that we must include the following information:

·         Bank account information required for wire transfers.
·         A document proving your current address, dated not more than 3 months from present date (e.g., and electricity bill usually works).
·         A handwritten request to change the name of the boat.

When we asked about changing the home port, we were informed that there was a home port for the Customs Office and a home port for the Maritime Administration and they are not necessarily the same.  The Maritime Administration suggested we change the home port for the Maritime Administration but leave the Customs Office home port as it was, since that service will soon be restructured to have a central service anyway.  This then gives us:

·         Fill out the form requesting the change of home port ; present this request to the Customs Offices  Maritime Administration of  both the current home port and the new home port.

To be honest, everyone was very kind, efficient, and helpful, despite that daft web site that is clearly maintained by some pin head bureaucrat in an office in Paris who has little or no contact with the services for whom he is the sole information provider.  The Maritime Administration even accepted our file at 16h32 when the sign on the door clearly said they closed at 16h00. And it didn’t cost us anything, unless you count the 3 hours of driving between Vannes and Nantes.  It could have been much worse.

But it’s too early for champagne.  We still have to contact the Radio Frequency Administration to register the VHF radio under the name of the new owner and boat name (Patrick is looking that one up on “The Official Web Site of the French Administration” as I type … heh, heh, heh) and we have to notify our port authorities of the changes, which undoubtedly requires forms and photos.

After these last few steps, Spray will be fully registered with the French authorities.  Then we’ve just got Neptune and that creepy sea serpent to deal with (see earlier posts).

Saturday, 2 June 2012

Dehler 34 Owners !

The check passing hands.
That giant sucking sound you heard around 19h00 GMT centered somewhere over western Europe was the siphon that just started in our bank account.  We’re officially poor boat owners! 



Antoine and Caroline, the charming FORMER owners of Zephyr/Spray, met us at the boat yard to discuss the crack around the propeller shaft tube.  We agreed on a price for fixing it and then drove to our home to sign the papers and celebrate with a little bubbly. 

The keys passing hands.



Neither of us knows quite what we’re supposed to do now.  We’re thrilled, anxious, overwhelmed, and aware that we’ve just accomplished a dream that has motivated our decisions and actions for the last 2 years.  A new chapter of our lives has indeed begun, with a glaring blank screen and a blinking cursor.  More champagne anyone ?

Time for champagne !

The Happy New Owners !

Thursday, 31 May 2012

The Naked Truth


Exibit A
When we inspected the boat during our first visit, I noticed a patch of rust on the hull around the propeller shaft tube (see exhibit A).  “That’ll clean right up with a good wire brush and a new layer of gelcoat - nothing to worry about,” I was told. 

Exhibit B
We were convinced that the rust was actually coming from the junction of the tube and the prop shaft seal (see exhibit B), which is not particularly worrisome, and can, indeed, be fixed with a wire brush and a little extra polyesther putty.


Now that Spray is “naked like a worm”, as Patrick says, following the sand/water blast of the hull, we see that our trusty rust patch was actually the only thing plugging a crack between the shaft tube and the hull (see exhibit C).  How long it has been there and how much damage the infiltration has caused is unknown and largely unknowable without exploratory surgery.

Exhibit C
The mechanic offered an Armageddon scenario involving a completely rusted shaft tube and massive flooding, with a 30% chance of making it back to port before the boat sinks even with the bilge pumps operating at full capacity.  (Okay, those were not his exact words, but that's what I heard.)  Thankfully, for a mere 2000 Euros, it appears we can avoid all this.  We called in the big guns (Guru Bob and another motor-head friend) to get additional opinions.

In short, they both agree that this is not something to ignore or something that can be treated with a slap of putty in the offending areas.  Guru Bob drew us a graph of the problem, where the red circles indicate our leaks:

Propellor Shaft Tubes 101 by Guru Bob.
We were lucky to be located next to an expert working on a neighbouring boat who overhead the conversation and came over with his hygrometer to check the humidity of the hull.  Everything was fine, even around the affected area.  This is not to say there is no infiltration but simply that the hull material itself has not absorbed any water.

As fate would have it, this discovery comes only 72 hours *BEFORE* we are supposed to sign the final bill of sale.  To be honest, if we can split the costs of replacing the shaft, seal, tube, and stratification, it may be to our advantage to go ahead and have the work done, even if the doomsday scenario is unlikely. The disadvantages?  1) stress in a negotiation process that has heretofore been exemplary, 2) 1000 Euros out of our pockets for the work, and 3) 2 more months in dry-dock !?  There are 2 “stratification guys” that work at our boat yard, and they have an accumulated 1000 hours of work in front of them before they can get to us.  This being France and this being summer, only one of them will be working at any given time in July or August.

Another new concern:  when I mentioned that the current owner had stratified the rudder a year ago, the expert raised his eyebrows in surprise and informed us that this tends to add a lot of weight to the rudder.  Having rapidly perused the Dehler Owner Association forum, it seems that the Dehlers have a rather sensitive rudder system, so now I’m a bit concerned about this potential problem as well.  The owner says it only added 3 kilograms, and anyway, the sandblast just removed it all.  Further investigation required.  For now, I hear a very large Gin and Tonic calling my name.
Posted on Thursday, May 31, 2012 | Categories:

Friday, 25 May 2012

Cracks in the Luddite


Despite having a big fat diploma from a major technology institute, I’m not a gadget geek. I don’t even have a cell phone, nor do I want one. Honestly, if I wanted to be tracked every moment of every day, I’d have a chip installed under my skin. But when the Kindle came out and my fellow book-lovers raved about it, my luddite shell developed a few cracks. I argued, I squirmed, I launched counter-attacks, all of which blew up in my face the day someone said “Hey, this thing would be great on a boat.”  Just damn. 

Not only can I carry my whole library with me, it fits inside the pocket of my sailing jacket (those large outside ones anyway).  And I can get new books delivered in seconds anywhere and anytime I have an internet connection.  And it’s cheaper than buying physical books, with the added advantage that no one can see what I’m reading !  And, the final nail in the coffin: I can get over 1000 kilograms of books into 250 grams of Kindle*, not to mention the space savings.  Just so that I don’t sound like a born-again convert, the Kindle cannot replace technical publications or guides because of the limited graphics ability and screen size, so my new boat will not be bookless by any means.  I also will sorely miss those charming book swaps in the port offices of many destinations and may take along a few paperbacks from time to time just to have something swapable on hand.
*estimate based on Kindle capacity of approx. 3500 books, with an average weight of 340 grams each.

Just as I was getting over the fact that I’d caved in over the Kindle, Patrick came home one day last week and proudly announced that he had just bought an MP3 player.  He went straight for the jugular:  “This will be great on the boat – we can listen to the radio, download all our music and cds, and buy a docking station with speakers to use instead of installing a traditional radio / cd player on the boat.  Think of all the space and weight we’ll save !”  I could feel the blood draining from my face.  I was about to throw out some feeble arguments such as “but we don’t even like music” or “it’s dangerous to plug your ears during your watch”, but then I thought of all those great radio shows I could download from NPR and BBC.  With a tear in my eye, I could already see myself standing behind the helm on the high seas, tapping my toes to the latest from NPR’s Mountain Stage. With a smile on my face, I imagined myself laughing with Click and Clack on Car Talk.  And with chin-in-hand in a thoughtful pose, I knew that the BBC’s In Our Time would take up a lot of my spare time.

I have no choice but to admit defeat in the face of the space, weight, and money-saving advances in home (boat) entertainment, but this sure puts a crimp in my “back to nature” ideas.  I’ve decided to treat this like any other potential addiction and will keep telling myself that a gadget now and again isn’t necessarily a bad thing, and that I can stop anytime I want.

Monday, 21 May 2012

On Horsepower and Hull Speed

An anonymous reader (I feel like I’m doing science again – responding to reviewer comments !) pointed out that the original 18 HP engine for the Dehler is a bit underpowered, and that we might consider upgrading to something stronger.  We had always used a simple rule of thumb to judge the appropriate size of the motor:  the horsepower of the motor, multiplied by 2, should be greater than the length of the boat in feet.  So an 18 HP engine gives a result of 36, which is greater than the 34 feet of the boat, indicating that the engine is about right for the boat.  This method, you realize, is total nonsense, since you don’t push length, you push weight.  I decided to get to the bottom of all this.

A brief tour of the web in both French and English provided a better rule of thumb:  for a sailboat, you need approximately 5 HP of power for every ton.  The Dehler’s displacement is about 4 tons, so we need 20 HP to push it, which suggests that the original 18 HP engine is, indeed, a bit on the small side. 

A nice example of a wave of a boat at hull speed.
Being a bit more rigorous, I decided to estimate the theoretical hull speed and then calculate the power required to reach that speed.  Let me explain.  As a sailboat moves through water, it has to push the water out of its way, and thus creates a bow wave that moves along the side of the boat as the water is displaced.  As the boat gains speed, this wave gets “stretched” and becomes longer.  When the boat reaches its hull speed, the wave length is equal to the length of the boat, creating a lovely sine wave* with a crest starting at the bow, a trough in the middle, and the end crest at the stern. If you were to go beyond this speed, you would stretch the wave to the point where the trough that was once in the middle of the boat would now be at the stern.  This literally means that the boat’s stern would be in a trough and that the boat would now have to go uphill, requiring an excessive amount of energy to overcome.  Sailboats under sail alone (at least monohull displacement boats) don’t have the power to do this. 
* okay, physical oceanography friends, I know that ocean waves are actually trochoids and not sine waves, but let’s keep it family friendly here, shall we?

The method for calculating theoretical hull speed and the power required to reach it are, of course, riddled with assumptions and highly criticized.  But let’s throw caution to the wind and judge the value of the method depending on whether or not we like the result it gives.  (Gee, now I REALLY feel like I’m back doing science again !).  Here are the equations:

(1) Hull speed = 1.34 x square root (length at waterline in feet).     (result is in knots)
  
(2) Power required to reach hull speed = Displacement (in pounds) / ((150)^2 / (hull speed)^2)     (where the symbol ^2 means to square the expression in parentheses).

Plug-n-chug the numbers for the Dehler and you get a theoretical hull speed of about 7 knots (significant figures would be total fantasy here), and a power requirement of 20 HP.

So the good news is that this answer jives with the (much simpler) rule of thumb of 5 HP per ton and suggests once again that the 18 HP on the Dehler is underpowered, or at least not powerful enough to reach the boat’s theoretical hull speed.  Now, most sailors, when faced with the theoretical hull speed of their craft, take on an indignant tone and announce that they have routinely sailed in excess of this speed.  This illustrates one of the criticisms of the estimation.  The “1.34” constant in Equation 1 is for a boat that moves by displacing water, as is the case for most sailboats.  Naval architect Dave Gerr has recently revised this constant, and now proposes 1.49 instead of 1.34, which gives us a speed of almost 8 knots for the Dehler.  This new number, however appealing, still doesn’t take into consideration the true motion of modern boats through water.  Modern design has made the sterns wider and flatter, giving the boat (and the crew) a more comfortable motion when wind and waves are from astern.  This also means that the boat has the ability to plane, or surf, as it slides down the waves, and when it does this, a fraction of the boat’s motion is no longer via displacement, but rather by planing, which requires a different calculation.  But even I don’t want to go there, and even if I did, I don’t have the numbers required to calculate this for my boat.    

Others cast aspersions on Equation 2, noting that propeller efficiency is never considered here.  What you calculate is just the energy required to turn the propeller shaft, but this doesn’t make allowances for how that motion is translated into push by different blades and blade-angle considerations.  The other problem is that this number only tells you the power required to reach a certain speed for a certain weight on a flat calm body of water with no wind.

So what have we learned?  I am now convinced that the 18 HP on the Dehler is not sufficient for us to reach the theoretical hull speed.  But now comes the real conundrum.  Is that something I really want to do?  As with most problems, the key is to appropriately formulate the question.  What is it I really want to know?  Am I asking “what is the biggest engine I can put on my boat without incurring structural damage or doing back-flips?” or “what size engine should I have to get me out of sticky situations (no wind, rapid currents) but that will not penalize me in terms of weight or fuel efficiency for the other 99% of the time when I am not in a sticky situation?”

Having recently read Lin and Larry Pardey’s excellent book, “The Self-Sufficient Sailor” where they extol the virtues of doing everything by sail and using the empty motor compartment to install a homemade bathtub, I’m leaning more towards the “less-is-more” approach.  In any case, this whole discussion is a bit academic for us, since we don’t have the money to install a new engine right now. 

But the real question that I should be asking, the one that will really get to the bottom of everything in a useful manner is, “What does my INSURANCE AGENT think is the biggest engine I can put on my boat?”.

Now I’m really in a pickle.  (“In a pickle” is another hillbilly expression meaning in a big mess.)  My insurance agent will simply look at the “maximum HP rating” for the boat, and, here in France, will officially allow a tolerance of 15% over this number.  If I look on the constructer’s plates, I see that the maximum power for my boat is 9.8 kilowatts.  With 1 HP = 0.746 kW, that gives me a maximum HP of (gulp) 13 !  Even with the 15% tolerance, the original 18 HP Dehler engine is already “too powerful” !?  I’m bamboozled.  Either I’m missing a conversion somewhere or there is some sort of interpretation of this number that escapes me.*

With a quivery chin, I broke down and decided I needed help on this one, so I sent an email to a friend who is a retired naval architect and spent many years as an expert boat inspector for an insurance company.  He estimates that with the 18 HP motor between 2/3rd – 3/4th  full throttle on the Dehler, I should be able to do 6 knots, which, in his opinion, is sufficient to get out of sticky situations, even if it wouldn’t allow us to go anywhere we want, anytime we want (although he also notes that our folding 2 blade propeller will reduce our efficiency somewhat).  A quick survey of the available French boating forums also suggests that the insurance companies really don’t care what size motor you put on the boat as long as it’s “reasonable” and that it is declared with them before you have an accident involving excessive speed. 

In the end, I like my friend’s summary of the situation, in part because it makes sense and in part because it accords with the limitations of our bank account at the moment:  when discussing the need to go beyond 6 knots with the motor, he simply replied, “After all, it’s a SAIL boat.”


*Addendum:  Now that we have the original papers for the boat, I see that the maximum HP rating is 19.8 kilowatts, not 9.8 !  Apparently, the “1” etched on the metal builders plate has not stood the test of time.  19.8 kilowatts gives 26.5 HP, which makes more sense.  The Dehler 34s were originally delivered with either 18HP or 27HP.  

For further and more comprehensive reading on the subject:
  1. The most excellent article by Bryon Anderson on The Physics of Sailing in Physics Today, now available on-line for free.
  2. Excellent posts on the forum of www.boatdesign.net
  3. The great post on Pocket Yacht Cruising entitled “Sailboat Math"


Wednesday, 16 May 2012

Tool Time


Spray / Zephyr back on the hard.
Our “To Do” list is long and we haven’t even finished signing all the paperwork yet.  While the jobs all seem relatively simple, I’m getting anxious to sail.  It’s a zoo on the water in southern Brittany in July and August and we’d like to get out for a few good shake-down cruises without too many on-lookers or obstacles. 

Spray (still officially named Zephyr…see earlier posts) is in the boatyard waiting for a water/sand blast (“hydrogommage”) of the hull and keel, and an epoxy job for the keel. The boat is in administrative limbo right now, since we have signed a “promise to buy” with a down payment, but aren’t officially the owners yet.  Last week, we started cracking open our piggy banks to pool resources for the big check, but doing this through several banks takes time, especially in France, especially in May, which has one official holiday per week where nothing gets done. I'm living the Randy Travis tune, "If the phone still ain't ringing, I assume it still ain't you."

But down time is not wasted time and we’ve decided to start going through the garage to determine how many hammers, screwdrivers, wrenches, etc. we have, with any duplicates going into “the boat toolbox”.  We’ll also need to considerably augment our meagre collection to tackle even those “simple” initial jobs already on our list.  I’m counting on the miracles of WD-40 and Duct Tape, myself.